Monday, September 24, 2012

Hapax legomenon in Copala Triqui

The word quita'a' which appears in this verse (Romans 14:14) is the only instance of this word in the New Testament, and I am not clear what it is supposed to mean.


Here is the PDF of the relevant passage in Romans:


It seems as if it might be a form of the verb ta'aa 'take, catch', but what causes the final glottal stop to appear?

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Wrong font in FLEx


I thought I would share a silly little trick I stumbled upon recently.

If you cut and paste examples from some other document (e.g. Word) into a FLEx  example field, often the font or style looks weird.




 I believe that FLEx is trying to retain the font from the other document.

You can select the example, go to the toolbar and select the correct style (usually Default Paragraph).

But a quick and easy way to accomplish the same thing is to select the example, cut it, and then paste it back.  After the text is pasted in, it goes into the correct font.

Now it looks like this:


Saturday, September 15, 2012

Gentiles = people apart

I worked out today that the phrase yuvii yaníj , literally 'people who are apart' is the phrase which translates 'Gentile' or 'Greek' in the Copala Triqui translation of the New Testament, as in the following passage:



Yuvii  is the ordinary word for 'people', and yaníj means 'apart, separated'.  So the combination 'people apart' or 'separated people' means 'Gentile'.

Here is an example of yaníj used in its more usual way to mean 'apart':


Thursday, September 13, 2012

More on affirmative vaa in Triqui

In a previous entry here, I talked about the myserious vaa ne that comes at the end of many lines in our texts.

I noted that Barbara Hollenbach in her sketch of Copala Triqui writes
 'The verbs vaa32 'to exist' and uun1 'to become' often take a sentence of any type as a subject complement with no complementizer.  These verbs serve to affirm the truth of the complement sentence, and they can follow the complement as well as precede it'. 
This is an important clue to understanding syntax of such sentences.  The final vaa takes the preceding material as a subject complement.

However as I look at more examples, it is not clear that it correct to say that they affirm the truth of the preceding complement.  For some cases where the speaker is talking about future events, the vaa seems to express a hope that that the statement will be true.

Consider the following examples:


In this example, vaa comes after the clause 'and hopefully will live for three thousand years in this world.'  But it doesn't seem right to say that the speaker is affirming the truth of a hope.

Another example of the same thing:



Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Copala Triqui asa' 'when'

The Triqui complementizer asa' is rather unusual in its syntax.  It means 'when' for future events.  However, it is not followed by a verb in the potential aspect — the usual way to show future in Triqui.

Instead it is usually followed by the completive aspect, as in the following two examples:


This example seems to say literally  'I will speak to you when I arrived…'

The next example is also interesting:


In this example, look at the two instances of the verb 'yaj 'make, do'.  Both refer to future events, and the first instance has the regular morphology of potential aspect — qui'yaj.  The second instance follows asa', so it instead appears in the completive form qui'yaj.

This is somewhat reminiscent of the inversion of normal aspect morphology after the negative particle, when semantic future shows up with completive morphology.  However, after the negative, we also get the reverse — semantic past shows up with potential morphology.  The shift after asa' happens in only one direction.

Possibly we want to think of certain morphemes like asa' as having floating autosegmental material that suppresses the normal low register for the following verb?

Monday, September 10, 2012

Pop quiz on Dari spelling

To make sure that the students are learning the orthography, I'm giving them some pop quizzes like the following, where the task is to match spelling and phonetics.


Saturday, September 8, 2012

Imageability, concreteness, and metaphor identification

This image shows a nice example of our metaphor identification procedure.  Each word in  a paragraph is graphed for its imageability and concreteness score, and
a.) highly imageable words
b.) that do not have a close semantic relationship to the topic of the paragraph
are likely to be metaphors.


The core of the imageability and concreteness rankings comes from psycholinguistic research, and we've expanded this core enormously by using WordNet sister terms to approximate these scores for words not contained in the original database.

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Puzzling verb in Copala Triqui

It puzzles me that the verb achríj rá seems to mean both 'realize' and 'suspect'.  These have different properties of factivity in English -- the complement of 'realize' must be a fact, while the complement of 'suspect' does not have to be.  The same seems to be true for Spanish darse cuenta and sospechar.

We explained this to our speaker, who understands the difference between the English and Spanish, but still thinks the Triqui might mean both.  It's interesting that the Triqui lexicon divides up the semantic space of cognition differently that English.

Here's our current (imperfect!) entry for achríj rá:


Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Working a bit with the Advanced Search feature at Dadegan today.  I'm trying to make sure I understand all the menu options.



This search looks for the verb خوردن ' eat'  with غذا 'food' as its object.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Persian Dependency analyses

I've been exploring the uses of Dadegan,  a database of Persian sentences that have been manually annotated with a syntactic analysis.

Here is a fairly simple example, where we search for the valence pattern of خوردن /khordan/ 'eat'




The first line shows the valence pattern.  Pink is the subject, yellow is the object (and the  را accusative marker is highlighted), and blue is the verb.

The screenshot doesn't show this, but when you put your mouse on the example sentences, various words in Farsi show the same highlights as the valence pattern.  In the example selected, من غذا خوردهام,  the subject is من /man/ 'I', the object is غذا /qaza/ 'food', and the verb is an inflected form of خوردن.

In the dependency analysis, the arc between the final verb and the subject is labelled فاعل ٫ /fa'al/ 'subject', and the arc between the object and the verb is labelled مفعول /mafa'ul/ 'object.

Each dependency analysis also has an abstract root, labelled ریشه ٫ /rishe/ 'root'.

Here is a more complex example of a screen shot from the Dadegan project:


This is a bit hard to interpret for a non-Persian speaker!

The analysis style is Dependency Grammar, in the style of Tesnĩere.   Here is what I understand so far:

The search is for the verb رسیدن /rasidan/  'arrive' .  The results are grouped by the type of valence pattern that appears with this verb.  When you click on a sentence, you see the dependency-tree analysis of it.

The first constituent is سنگئ که زورت نمی رسد, approximately 'the stone that you cannot move (?)'.
 This is connected by an arc to the word بکن, which is the first verb of the sentence.  The arc is labelled مفعول  'object/patient', so the first constituent is the object of the clause.
The relationship between بوشه and بکن is labelled فعل یار, which I think means something like 'co-verb'.  (It seems to be literally 'friend of the verb'.) بوشه کردن /bushe kardan/ is a compound 'do a kiss';

The last two words are linked by و 'and'.  The label between 'and' and its left sister is همپايه, which means 'cohort, equal'.

The main verb is بگذر, and I think this is the imperative of the verb گذر 'pass'.  A helpful person at Wordreference suggests the translation 'If you cannot drag a stone from your way, kiss it and change your path.' 

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Persian chrestomathy

One of the ways in which I'm trying to teach myself Farsi is by working with texts which already have an analysis available.   I stumbled on an old, but rather nice resource on Google Play (the stupid new name for Google Books).

The book was published in 1857 by Arthur Henry Bleeck.A concise grammar of the Persian language: containing dialogues, reading lessons, and a vocabulary: together with a new plan for facilitating the study of languages 

 It starts with a brief grammatical overview, but then there are 100+ pages of text/analysis.  Typically every other page has a paragraph of Persian, with translation, and every word is given in the vocabulary below and facing this paragraph.
Here is an example:



I've been adding this text to my FLEx project as a learning exercise.  Here is a little of the text in my preliminary analysis:



This aid to learning a language was called a chrestomathy;  I don't think that they are much used anymore, but they work pretty well for my purposes.

It would be nice if the Persian were in electronic format, so that I didn't have to retype it.  But it has the side advantage of making me pay more attention to the text as it goes in.  More easily accessible electronic texts don't have the advantage of an analysis...

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Farsi language learning software

I am trying to learn Farsi this summer for one of our research projects.

I've been exploring two online language learning systems.  One is Headstart2, developed by the military for soldiers.  But it seems that anyone can register and use the system for free.

Some features for Headstart2

  • In each unit, there is an initial vocabulary introduction section, then a subsequent group of exercises in increasing difficulty that involve using this vocabulary.
  • For example, in the following screenshot, the system is helping the user learn words that describe people, such as 'old', 'fat', 'man', 'blonde', 'tall', etc.


The question at the bottom asks "Who is the short man?"   The pictures alone are often enough to answer, but the text underneath the first picture ("Amir is short") also helps, especially when it is not completely obvious from the picture.
  • Some tasks can be rather complex, as in the following screen, where you need to be able to read the names of cities, days, and times in order to find the right flight.


Some likes and dislikes:
  • You can always go back and forth in the lessons to double check vocabulary.
  • You can play sound clips of all the words
  • The system also teaches you to read the Farsi alphabet
  • The lessons get complex fairly quickly.  I think it might be a bit overwhelming for some users.
  • There is a link for a 'glossary', but this doesn't work for me.  So there is no single place that all the vocabulary is collected
  • There are tests at the end of each chapter, so you can check your progress.

The second system is Mango .  My library system has a subscription for patrons.

Mango has a simpler rotation of activities.  It is always along the lines of 

English1   ---  Farsi1
English1  ---  ?

where at the prompt, you are supposed to say the Farsi word.  The system is based on a spaced repetition model, so it is similar overall to Pimsleur, but it presents the material in both written and audio form.

Here is a sample screenshot


If you mouse over the words, you can see their transcription or play any word individually.  The play button at the left plays the whole thing.   

The general approach for each section is to present a long phrase, then break it apart into constituent parts, drill each separately (interleaving them), then recombine them into the whole phrase at the end of the section.

Likes and dislikes
  • As with Headstart2, there is no central vocabulary that collects all the words.
  • All the words are presented in Farsi orthography.  Since I know how to read this alphabet, this works for me.  But I also tried a little of the Mandarin course, and without knowing any characters, it was much, much more difficult to do the lessons.  (Essentially it then works without any readable written portion, if you exclude the mouse-over transcriptions.)
  • The variety of tasks is low.
A possible weakness of both programs -- I see drilling/repetition of words within a chapter.  But once you've left the chapter on colors (for instance), the color words don't seem to reappear in the subsequent chapters, so it would be easy to forget them.

Both systems are far advanced above what is available for the endangered languages I know.  Would it be possible for one of these authoring systems to be made available to people working on small/endangered languages?  

I know that Rosetta Stone is working with Navajo and Chitimacha on language preservation and revitalization projects.  Unfortunately, I don't have access to their product on Farsi for a comparison to the other two.

Monday, June 18, 2012

Homograph numbers as an aid to merging entries

In a previous post I mentioned the issue of merging what are separate entries in Cordova's dictionary of Colonial Valley Zapotec.

Today I experimented with using the Homograph Numbers feature in FLEx to help me locate these entries.  In the configure columns menu, one of the options is Homograph Numbers.  I chose to restrict that entries with a homograph number greater than 0.  (Ordinary entries don't have homograph numbers; they are only assigned when two entries have identical Lexeme Forms.)



This locates about 6000 entries where there is a homograph.  In this screenshot, zèni is both 'tomar en la mano' and 'tener en la mano', so these entries should be merged.

Unfortunately, that still leaves me with lots of entries to look at -- some of them should be merged and some should not, but you need to look at the translations to decide.

I think the homograph number method would also fail to catch entries that are mostly identical, but differ by the placement of an accent, e.g. if there were an entry zéni that means the same thing as zèni.

Friday, June 15, 2012

Merging entries from Cordova's colonial Zapotec dictionary

A couple of weeks ago, I managed to import all of Cordova's 1567 dictionary of Spanish into my FLEx project.

Since that book is Spanish -- Zapotec, one thing that is revealed by created a project that can sort on the Zapotec is how many times Zapotec words are listed under multiple translations in Spanish.  This gives us a much better sense of the range of meanings of the Zapotec word.

Consider the following merged entry for aba-queta 'fall', which combines information from six different Spanish - Zapotec entries

.  

Here it would not have been too difficult to see this, since all but one are listed under caer 'fall' in Spanish.

But the value is much clearer when the Spanish glosses are more various.   Consider the following entry for aate 'harden',  where the various Spanish glosses are not alphabetically adjacent.  Nor is the idea that the same word is used for freezing and hardening obvious.


Thursday, June 14, 2012

Senses of psychological verbs in Copala Triqui

It is very difficult to accurately translate all the different psychological and emotional verbs into English or Spanish, since Triqui divides the world up somewhat differently.

Case in point is the verb aráya'anj , which has a range of meanings that includes 'be amazed at something; be concerned about someone; be alarmed at something.'   Working through the large corpus with this verb allows us to find examples that show the different shades of meaning.



Here's an example of the 'be concerned' sense:


Here is an example of the 'be amazed' sense


And here is an example of the 'alarmed'  sense



The common semantics of this verb seem to include an aspect of worry/lack of knowledge about the future and concern for people affected in the future.

We also see this verb in combination with the ni'yanj psych marker to show an attitude of amazement toward someone.


Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Accidentally working with different project versions in FLEx -- how to fix the problem

I was away for a couple of weeks and my graduate student was working with our Triqui FLEx database.  She and our native speaker colleague were looking for entries where there was no example sentence and he was creating examples for these entries.

Unfortunately, when I got back and we looked at the project together, we saw that she had accidentally opened and modified an old version of the project.

At first, I thought we would just have to look for the entries modified in the old project and cut and paste them to the new, but after a bit of thought, I found a much easier way.  Since this problem is likely to arise in any collaborative FLEx project, it's possibly useful to others as well.

Since I knew the dates that she had worked with our speaker while I was away, the first step was to go to Bulk Edit and add the Date Modified field to the Column Choices.  The Restrict choice lets you select the dates that you want to look at.


Once I had done this, I could see that there were 14 entries modified during this time.

So I exported these entries from the older version of the project via LIFT.  Then I imported the same entries into the current project version.



This resulted in a little bit of duplication.  Luckily the import log that is produced showed me all the entries where this was an issue:


What I needed to then was to look at the entries for the listed conflicts.  The first one involved duplicated entries, so I used the Merge Entry feature to combine the two forms of ananj chij.  The other three conflicts involved duplicated senses, so I went to each entry and merged the senses.  (Pull-down menu to the left of the Sense label.)

It's still best to try to avoid working on different version of a project, and I don't know what the solution would be if the interlinear texts had been modified.  But if the accidental use of different versions only affects lexical entries, then
  • filtering by Date Modified, 
  • exporting entries from Project A, 
  • importing entries to Project B, and 
  • checking the Import Log for conflicts
results in a much simpler solution than cutting and pasting.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Culling blanks from the Colonial Zapotec

In the process of importing entries from Cordova dictionary of Colonial Valley Zapotec, I forgot that I needed to weed out the cases where the Zapotec Lexeme Form is blank.

This is generally because the original entry in Cordova is a cross reference.  For example:


Where we don't have a Zapotec word for the entry under Cepo de animales.  The underlying file from Thom Smith Stark's group has all of these listed as records with no Zapotec form.

That doesn't make much sense in a Zapotec- Spanish - English dictionary, so I weeded those out tonight. That results in a dictionary with 46,712 entries.  (There are still plenty of duplicates in there also...)

Here's a screenshot with the new number:


Sunday, June 3, 2012

The mercies of the Spanish man in the 16th century

From the Zapotec Doctrina of 1567.  There are still some parts of the Zapotec analysis to be worked out,  but of interest for its horrifying gender politics!

(Click to enlarge, if you dare...)


Friday, June 1, 2012

Cordova import complete!

I finished importing entries from the massive Cordova dictionary of Colonial Zapotec into the FLEx project today.  Lots of entries will need editing and clean-up, but it's great to have them all there finally.   At this point there are about 47,000 entries in the lexicon for Colonial Valley Zapotec -- lots of them probably will need to be merged, since each entry represents a different Spanish language translation in the original (with perhaps several different entries corresponding to the same Zapotec word).  But on the other hand, a lot of entries also need to be split, since more than one Zapotec word shows up in the entry.

Here's the screenshot of the last form that was imported.  Note the nice big number at the bottom on the left :)


Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Scilicet in Cordova dictionary entries

In the Cordova dictionary of Colonial Valley Zapotec, the abbreviation scillicet means 'that is, for example'.  In the Spanish orthography of the time, this is the long s followed by a period.  In Thom Smith Stark's markup, this is {¥s[cilicet].}

Here is a screenshot of a sample Cordova entry that uses this.




Almoçadas means something like 'handfuls' in Spanish.  The FLEx entry that shows my best guess of the correct interpretation of the Cordova entry is as follows:


I think the o in front of the word xoopa is probably Spanish o 'or'.

This example shows some of the difficulties of deciphering all the information that Cordova includes in his entries!