My friend Jack is working with Oklahoma Choctaws to produce an audio dictionary that will use their preferred spelling system. I'm working this morning on a quick review of the entries. Here is a screenshot:
One big regret of my own work with Choctaw is that I didn't use the traditional orthography enough, which alienates some Choctaw communities who are attached to it.
In my defense I have to say -- the traditional orthography is terrible. Choctaw has a vowel length distinction not present in the traditional orthography, and the orthography also uses two different symbols for each of the three phonemic vowels /a, i, o/, which are written according to how the 19th century missionaries perceived the vowel quality. Instances of /a/ that sounded more like schwa were written with the symbol <ʋ>.
But something I understand now that I did not understand as well when I was a grad student is that orthographies don't have to be good to be useful to native speakers. I would think that my advice to someone starting to work with a community is that if there is any orthography which speakers can use, you should stick with it.
One big regret of my own work with Choctaw is that I didn't use the traditional orthography enough, which alienates some Choctaw communities who are attached to it.
In my defense I have to say -- the traditional orthography is terrible. Choctaw has a vowel length distinction not present in the traditional orthography, and the orthography also uses two different symbols for each of the three phonemic vowels /a, i, o/, which are written according to how the 19th century missionaries perceived the vowel quality. Instances of /a/ that sounded more like schwa were written with the symbol <ʋ>.
But something I understand now that I did not understand as well when I was a grad student is that orthographies don't have to be good to be useful to native speakers. I would think that my advice to someone starting to work with a community is that if there is any orthography which speakers can use, you should stick with it.
No comments:
Post a Comment